Share from 0:00
0:00
/

#39 When the Numbers Don't Add Up: Steven Emerman's Independent Assessment of the Metals Company Pre-Feasibility Study

What a geophysicist from outside the deep sea mining world found when he read the financial fine print

Steven Emerman, owner of Malach Consulting and a former Princeton and Cornell-trained geophysicist, brings an unusual perspective to deep sea mining. He came to it from decades of evaluating mining disclosures across the terrestrial mining industry. Commissioned by the Deep Sea Mining Campaign, Greenpeace International, and Mining Watch Canada, Emerman reviewed The Metals Company’s pre-feasibility study not as an ecological or policy document, but strictly as a financial and regulatory one. His conclusion: even under the company’s most optimistic assumptions — best-case metal prices, a below-standard discount rate, and a novel category of “recoverable resources” not recognized under SEC regulations — the project’s own numbers show it terminating at the end of year seven with zero profit.

What makes this conversation particularly valuable for listeners tracking the commercial viability debate is Emerman’s grounding in mining industry norms. He walks through why the distinction between reserves and resources matters so much to investors, why the zero-tailings claim reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of ore processing chemistry, and why the assumed smelting and refining capacity in Indonesia involves layers of speculation that the PFS doesn’t adequately address. He’s careful to distinguish what the document does and doesn’t disclose and what it’s required to disclose under SEC regulations. His full report is available publicly and is referenced throughout this episode.

Chapters

00:00 – Introduction and context for the conversation
01:03 – Who is Steven Emmerman? Background and consulting work
04:14 – Previous involvement in deep-sea mining discussions
05:20 – How this report came about
06:33 – What “independence” means in consulting
08:12 – Handling client pressure and report revisions
11:02 – Personal views vs scope of the report
12:32 – Podcast framing and approach to the discussion
15:49 – What is a pre-feasibility study (PFS)?
16:24 – The stage-gate process in mining projects
18:23 – Internal vs public role of PFS documents
20:00 – Regulation and the role of independent experts
23:36 – What is a “qualified person”?
25:42 – Key conclusion: should the project proceed?
26:11 – How this compares to typical PFS evaluations

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?